| | Carol Choir Conductors |
| c.1870-1910 | Mr Thornhill and members of the Smith family |
| 1911-1918 | Ted Smith |
| 1919-1931 | Walter Bostock |
| 1932-1939 | Eddie Reading |
| 1940-1948 | Harold Sansom |
| 1949-1951 | Harold Sansom and Margaret Cooper |
| 1952 | Margaret Cooper and Bert Taylor |
| 1953-1958 | Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor and George Bostock |
| 1959 | Margaret Cooper and Bert Taylor |
| 1960-1971 | Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor and Les Williams |
| 1972-1979 | Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor and George Bostock |
| 1980-1984 | Margaret Cooper and Bert Taylor |
| 1985-1992 | Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor and Jenny Weir |
| 1993-1996 | Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor, Jenny Weir and Liz Nesbitt |
| 1997-2004 | Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor, Jenny Weir, Liz Nesbitt and Andrew Taylor |
| 2005-2006 | Andrew Taylor, Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor, Jenny Weir, Liz Nesbitt, Hilary Phillips, Mark Ramsey and Ruth Steggles |
| 2007 | Andrew Taylor, Margaret Cooper, Bert Taylor, Jenny Weir, Hilary Phillips, Mark Ramsey and Ruth Steggles |
| 2008-2009 | Andrew Taylor, Jenny Weir, Hilary Phillips, Mark Ramsey and Ruth Steggles |
| 2010-2014 | Andrew Taylor, Jenny Weir, Hilary Phillips, Mark Ramsey, Ruth Steggles and Serena Lindsay |
| 2015- | Andrew Taylor, Jenny Weir, Hilary Phillips, Mark Ramsey and Serena Lindsay |
